Saturday, April 21, 2007

Consensus 2

Because I wanted to remind you that there is no consensus, so if your argument is that it must be true because there's a consensus, then your argument is wrong, and you should now re evaluate and maybe even try to think for yourself.


Explanation

Listed below are 17,200 of the initial signers

During the past several years, more than 17,100 basic and applied American scientists, two-thirds with advanced degrees, have signed the Global Warming Petition.

Signers of this petition so far include 2,660 physicists, geophysicists, climatologists, meteorologists, oceanographers, and environmental scientists (select this link for a listing of these individuals) who are especially well qualified to evaluate the effects of carbon dioxide on the Earth's atmosphere and climate.

Signers of this petition also include 5,017 scientists whose fields of specialization in chemistry, biochemistry, biology, and other life sciences (select this link for a listing of these individuals) make them especially well qualified to evaluate the effects of carbon dioxide upon the Earth's plant and animal life.

Nearly all of the initial 17,100 scientist signers have technical training suitable for the evaluation of the relevant research data, and many are trained in related fields. In addition to these 17,100, approximately 2,400 individuals have signed the petition who are trained in fields other than science or whose field of specialization was not specified on their returned petition.

Of the 19,700 signatures that the project has received in total so far, 17,800 have been independently verified and the other 1,900 have not yet been independently verified. Of those signers holding the degree of PhD, 95% have now been independently verified. One name that was sent in by enviro pranksters, Geri Halliwell, PhD, has been eliminated. Several names, such as Perry Mason and Robert Byrd are still on the list even though enviro press reports have ridiculed their identity with the names of famous personalities. They are actual signers. Perry Mason, for example, is a PhD Chemist.

The costs of this petition project have been paid entirely by private donations. No industrial funding or money from sources within the coal, oil, natural gas or related industries has been utilized. The petition's organizers, who include some faculty members and staff of the Oregon Institute of Science and Medicine, do not otherwise receive funds from such sources. The Institute itself has no such funding. Also, no funds of tax-exempt organizations have been used for this project.

The signatures and the text of the petition stand alone and speak for themselves. These scientists have signed this specific document. They are not associated with any particular organization. Their signatures represent a strong statement about this important issue by many of the best scientific minds in the United States.

3 comments:

gary said...

Again,there is difference between consensus and unanimity. I have never said no scientists dispute manmade global warming.

SourcWatch on the petition and its sponsors:

http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=Oregon_Institute_of_Science_and_Medicine

This is PR, not science. Affiliation of the scientists is not given. Most are not climate scientists, or even scientists at all. Some have said they would not sign the petition today.

gary said...

Having nothing better to do I have taken 10 names at random from your list and googled them.

1) Orson L. Anderson - a minerologist

2) James Disenna - ARCO Oil and Gas Company

3) Clyde Hardin - mathematician

4) Williad Keckner, Ph.D. - no records of this fellow

5) David G. Pelka, Ph.D - physicist

6) Dr. George Vourvopoulous - Physicist

7) Petr CHylek Ph.D - Professor of Physical and Environmental Science

8) Martin E. Condigo - certified television meterology broadcaster

9) Edward Choulnard, Ph.D. - no records

10) David F. Cope Ph.D. - who signed twice - geographer

Anonymous said...

Denial springs eternal for the fucking stupid.

I guess measurment of the polar ice caps and continental glaciers year by year for the last 30 years is an inexact science.

While your head is up your ass, look around for my foot.